- Identifying a plant means assigning it to a species using several features: leaf arrangement, leaf shape and margin, flower, growth form and habitat. A single feature is never enough.
- An identification key leads you to the species question by question. Dichotomous keys offer exactly two alternatives at each step.
- Apps are a starting point, not proof: in an Estonian study, the first suggestion from Flora Incognita was correct at species level in 79.6 to 85.3 % of cases, so not always.
- What is not identified with certainty is not used. Not as tea, and not for smoking.
- Mild and Mild Silver consist of seven declared plant ingredients. You do not have to identify anything yourself for them, and we do not recommend collecting wild plants in order to smoke them.
Table of contents
- Loading...
Identifying plants is a craft, not guesswork. If you want to name a wild herb by the wayside, you look at leaf, flower, growth and habitat one after another and compare what you see with a key or a flora. Here is how that works, what apps can do and where they stop. One rule up front: what is not identified with certainty is not used.
How do you identify a plant?
Identifying means assigning a specimen to a species based on observed features and then finding its common or scientific name. To do this, you compare leaf arrangement, leaf shape, leaf margin, flower, growth form and habitat with an identification key or a flora. Pictures alone are usually not enough for a reliable identification.1
Illustrations help, but they do not replace the comparison. Identification becomes more reliable when a picture comes with a text that describes habitat, shape and distinguishing features.1 There is also a practical problem: some features cannot be seen at the time you observe the plant. With dandelions, the species can often only be told apart by their fruits.1
The leaf: arrangement, shape, margin
The leaf is often what you see first and for the longest time. Three questions will take you a long way.
How are the leaves arranged on the stem? In alternate arrangement there is one leaf per node, and the leaves follow one another in a spiral; this is typical of dicotyledons. Opposite means two leaves per node. If each pair is turned by 90° against the previous one, it is called decussate, as in the mint family, the pink family and the olive family. Whorled means three or more leaves at one node, as in woodruff.3
Simple or compound? In a simple leaf the blade is one continuous surface, as in the European aspen. A compound leaf consists of completely separate leaflets. If they sit along a common central axis, it is pinnate, as in the rose; if they radiate from one point, it is palmate, as in the horse chestnut.3
What does the margin look like? Botanical terminology distinguishes entire, toothed, serrate, sinuate and crenate margins.3 Then there are the stipules at the leaf base: in the rose family they are strongly developed, in linden and poplar they are thin and fall off early.3 Hairiness is also one of the leaf features that can be decisive for the species.1
The flower and the family
The flower usually tells you first which family a plant belongs to. In flowering plants, the inflorescence, the symmetry and the number of floral organs often reveal the family. For the species you generally need vegetative features as well: leaf arrangement, leaf shape, leaf margin and hairiness.1
A small habit is worth cultivating: note down or photograph both the flower and the leaf on the same shoot, and record where you found it. How to document finds permanently is described in Making a herbarium: pressing and documenting plants.
Growth and habitat
The growth form narrows the field early: tree, herb, grass, fern or succulent. Flora Incognita even lets you preselect this growth form.6
The habitat is a clue, but not proof. Indicator plants tolerate only small variations in their living conditions and therefore point to soil and climate. According to the indicator values of Heinz Ellenberg (first published in 1974), for example, stinging nettle and common chickweed are indicators of nitrogen-rich soils, wood sorrel is a shade indicator and coltsfoot indicates waterlogging.4 That is exactly why habitat is useful for narrowing things down but not for telling similar species apart: poisonous look-alikes sometimes grow in the same place as the edible plant.10
How does an identification key work?
An identification key is a sequence of questions or alternative features that leads from general to ever more specific characteristics until, as a rule, the species is established. Dichotomous keys offer exactly two alternatives per step, polytomous keys more than two. The structure resembles a decision tree.2
For practice, here are the first stages of such a key, using only the leaf features from above. It does not lead to a species, but to pointers on where to continue searching in the flora:
Step 1: Are there two leaves opposite each other at every node?
If yes, continue with step 2. If no, continue with step 3.
Step 2: Is each pair of leaves turned by 90° against the previous one?
If yes: decussate; this occurs in the mint family, the pink family and the olive family, among others. If no: opposite but arranged differently; look it up in the flora.
Step 3: Are there three or more leaves at one node?
If yes: whorled, as in woodruff. If no: alternate, one leaf per node, in a spiral.
Step 4: Is the blade divided into separate leaflets?
If yes: compound, pinnate (rose) or palmate (horse chestnut). If no: simple leaf (European aspen); then check the leaf margin.
Floras and software keys
For Germany, the Schmeil-Fitschen is a standard work.1 It has existed since spring 1904; the 96th edition appeared in 2016. Besides Germany, it covers Austria, Switzerland and the Benelux countries, among others.5 Identification books presuppose some basic botanical knowledge, and some features are not available at the time of observation.1
Electronic keys are more flexible: you can enter features in any order and do not have to work through a fixed sequence of questions. That helps when individual features are missing.1, 2 On the history of plant books: Renaissance herbals.
How good are plant identification apps?
A study with Flora Incognita in Estonia (2,494 observations, 588 species) found the first suggestion correct at species level in 79.6 % of database photos and 85.3 % of field photos, at genus level in over 89 % and at family level in over 95 %. In this study, the first suggestion was therefore wrong at species level in roughly 15 to 20 % of cases.8
| Flora Incognita | Pl@ntNet | |
|---|---|---|
| Developers | TU Ilmenau and Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry, Jena | French research institutes (including IRD, CIRAD, INRA, INRIA) and Tela Botanica |
| Number of species | about 16,000 worldwide (after the 2023 AI update); in 2020 it was 4,848 | over 45,000 identifiable plants (October 2023) |
| Sources | 6, 8 (see list below) | 7 (see list below) |
The authors of the Estonian study name the weaknesses themselves. Photos showing reproductive organs were recognised better than pictures with leaves only. Herbaceous plants reached 83.7 % correct species identifications, other growth forms 63.4 to 69.4 %. The apps struggled with grasses, knotweeds and similar white-flowered umbellifers; complex genera such as Rubus and Taraxacum were not fully resolved to species level in the study. The authors name as a possible limit that two-dimensional photos do not capture all variants of a plant and are taken outdoors in changing light, wind and precipitation.8
The developer team states 98.8 % on its website, after a reassessment of a British dataset in which the reference identifications were checked again. That is a self-reported figure.9 What remains for you: the app gives a suggestion, and the suggestion needs to be checked.
What is not identified with certainty is not used
Not identified with certainty means: do not use. Do not eat it, do not brew it as tea, and certainly do not dry it for smoking. An app, a photo or "looks like it" do not replace identification.
In March 2026, the consumer protection ministry of Baden-Württemberg expressly warned against relying blindly on apps or AI for identification: "Botanical distinction is vital." As an example, it named poisonous look-alikes that often grow in the same place as the edible plant.10
When in doubt, the ministry advises asking experienced herb experts or buying the plant in the shops.10 If you feel unwell after eating an unidentified plant, you can reach the Bonn poison information centre around the clock on +49 228 19240.13
We do not describe look-alikes species by species here, but in one place: in Plants that do not belong in a smoking blend.
What may you pick in the wild?
Under section 39(3) of the German Federal Nature Conservation Act (BNatSchG), anyone may take wild flowers, grasses, ferns, mosses, lichens, fruits, mushrooms, tea and medicinal herbs and twigs from places where entry is not prohibited, provided this is done in small quantities, for personal use and with care.11 The prerequisite is that you know what you are picking. Specially protected species, on the other hand, may not be taken from the wild, nor damaged, nor may their habitats be destroyed (section 44(1) no. 4).12 How to harvest and dry carefully the plants that you have lawfully and reliably identified is described in Harvesting and drying herbs. That is not a recommendation to smoke them, but craft knowledge.
Identifying plants and Ritual Herbs
Mild and Mild Silver contain the same seven plant ingredients: mullein leaves, blackberry leaves, lotus flower leaves, hollyhock leaves, turmeric leaves, liquorice root and liquorice leaves. They are listed in full on the packaging. We process the herbs in Germany, from cutting to balancing the recipe. Identifying a plant yourself in order to smoke it is not intended, and we advise against it. Which plants are under discussion at all can be found in Which herbs can you smoke? The range is available under Tobacco substitute.
What the plant families behind these ingredients have in common is explained in Plant families of smoking herbs.
Frequently asked questions
An Estonian study found the first suggestion from Flora Incognita correct at species level in 79.6 to 85.3 %, at genus level in over 89 % and at family level in over 95 %. Grasses and similar white-flowered umbellifers were harder. That is no substitute for your own check.8
Call the poison information centre. The centre in Bonn can be reached around the clock on +49 228 19240.13
An honest assessment
This text explains a method and replaces neither a flora nor an expert. The app figures come from a single study using an app version from 2020 (4,848 species); we have not found an independent re-measurement.
Tobacco-free does not mean risk-free. Smoke remains smoke: a review in ACS Omega (2022) lists carbon monoxide, polyaromatic compounds, nicotine and N-nitrosamines as pollutants in herbal cigarettes.14 A Korean study (2015) found more carbon monoxide and benzo[a]pyrene in the smoke of a herbal cigarette in which no nicotine was detectable than in the smoke of a tobacco cigarette; at the same concentration, the condensate was more strongly mutagenic. That concerns a single product, but it shows that "nicotine-free" is not a free pass.15
With Mild and Mild Silver, tobacco and nicotine are left out. We claim nothing more. They are not a health product and not a means of quitting smoking. If you want to stop, you can find free counselling at rauchfrei-info.de, the portal of the German Federal Institute for Public Health, and by phone on +49 800 8 31 31 31 (in German).16 Ritual Herbs is aimed at adults.
Read more
Sources
- Wikipedia (de): Pflanzenbestimmung. Retrieved in October 2026. Term, pictures, identification books, software keys, apps, standard works, family and species.
- Wikipedia (de): Bestimmungsschlüssel. Retrieved in October 2026. Dichotomous, polytomous, decision tree, synoptic keys.
- Wikipedia (de): Blatt (Pflanze). Retrieved in October 2026. Leaf arrangement, simple and compound, leaf margin terms, stipules.
- Wikipedia (de): Zeigerpflanze. Retrieved in October 2026. Ellenberg indicator values (1974), examples.
- Wikipedia (de): Schmeil-Fitschen. Retrieved in October 2026. First edition 1904, 96th edition 2016, area covered.
- Wikipedia (de): Flora Incognita. Retrieved in October 2026. Developers, how it works, number of species, cost.
- Wikipedia (de): Pl@ntNet. Retrieved in October 2026. Developers, launch, database, validation.
- Pärtel J, Pärtel M, Wäldchen J: Plant image identification application demonstrates high accuracy in Northern Europe. AoB Plants 13(4): plab050, 2021. PMC8387968 (full text opened via Europe PMC).
- Flora Incognita: Study on identification accuracy: Flora Incognita reaches 98.8 %. Developers' blog post, 24.10.2024. Self-reported figure, refers to Rzanny et al. 2024, People and Nature.
- Ministry of Food, Rural Affairs and Consumer Protection of Baden-Württemberg: Wichtige Tipps zum Start der Bärlauch-Saison (Important tips for the start of the wild garlic season). Press release of 11 March 2026.
- Federal Nature Conservation Act (BNatSchG), section 39: gesetze-im-internet.de. Retrieved in October 2026.
- Federal Nature Conservation Act (BNatSchG), section 44: gesetze-im-internet.de. Retrieved in October 2026.
- Poison information centre at Bonn University Hospital: Giftzentrale Bonn, plant page. Retrieved in October 2026. Emergency number +49 228 19240.
- Abdel Rahman RT, Kamal N, Mediani A, Farag MA: How Do Herbal Cigarettes Compare To Tobacco? ACS Omega 7(50): 45797–45809, 2022. PMC9773184.
- Bak JH, Lee SM, Lim HB: Safety assessment of mainstream smoke of herbal cigarette. Toxicological Research 31(1): 41–48, 2015. doi:10.5487/tr.2015.31.1.041 (abstract).
- Federal Institute for Public Health (BIÖG): rauchfrei-info.de. Retrieved in October 2026.