- Six works from five museums: Brouwer, Dou, Stevers, Andriessen, Courbet and Magritte, each with title, year, museum and a link to the museum page.
- According to the Museum voor Schone Kunsten Ghent, tobacco in Hendrick Andriessen's painting stands for the insignificance of earthly pleasures. Not every smoking picture is a warning picture, though.
- Magritte's "Ceci n'est pas une pipe" (1929, LACMA) asks whether a picture can be equated with the object.
- Mild and Mild Silver are tobacco-free and nicotine-free. Smoke is still smoke.
Table of contents
- Loading...
The pipe in art is rarely just a prop. With Adriaen Brouwer it belongs to a round of smokers, with Gerrit Dou it keeps a young man company at a window ledge, in a vanitas still life it lies next to the skull, and with René Magritte it is only the picture of a pipe. Here we go through six works, each with title, year and museum, and say what the museums write about the picture and what stays open.
Why do artists paint the pipe?
A study in Postmedieval Archaeology (2024) summarises the state of historical research like this: tobacco became more popular across all social classes in the Netherlands between 1590 and 1630. According to the authors, the pipe-making trade, which arose in 1609, contributed to this because a pipe lets you take in larger amounts of tobacco.1
According to the same study, the habit spread first among sailors and ordinary people who met in harbour taverns after work.1 The Victoria and Albert Museum writes about the long pipes in Dutch paintings of the 17th century that they were mostly smoked at home or in the tavern.2 Four of the six pictures here were made in that century.
Brouwer and Dou: smoking in the Dutch picture
Adriaen Brouwer: "The Smokers", around 1636
The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York holds "The Smokers", oil on wood, around 1636, 46.4 × 36.8 cm. The Met tags it with "Men", "Smoking" and "Tankards".3 It shows five men smoking. The curator Anita Jansen writes on the CODART Canon: "Contemporary sources, however, leave no doubt that it is a portrait." Brouwer portrayed himself with four colleagues, including Jan Lievens and Joos van Craesbeeck, in "a not-so-flattering, possibly realistic picture of his social network".4 The texts we read do not interpret the pipe as a warning sign; the Met record and the CODART text mention only the smoking itself.
Gerrit Dou: "Man Smoking a Pipe", around 1650 to 1655
The Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam owns Dou's "Man Smoking a Pipe", oil on wood, 48 × 36.6 cm. The museum text: "A young man leans on a window ledge, smoking a pipe and looking out at us." The open book on the ledge seems to project out of the window into our space, and the curtain is painted so deceptively that we want to pull it back. Then the sentence that sums the picture up: "However, the painting's small size gives away the deception."5 According to the Rijksmuseum, Dou was a master of illusionism. The museum writes nothing about the pipe itself; it describes the picture as a play with illusion.
More about the pipe itself can be found in Clay pipes and Holland: a history. How tobacco reached Europe is told in How tobacco came to Europe.
What is vanitas, and what does the pipe have to do with it?
The Kunsthalle Karlsruhe explains, in connection with a vanitas still life by Jacob Marrel (1637), that "Vanitas" means "vanity" in the old sense (German "Eitelkeit"), and that "eitel" can be equated with "worthless" or "transient" (our translation from the German museum text). Such still lifes point to the finiteness of earthly life.6 The Book of Ecclesiastes in the Luther Bible 2017 reads: "Es ist alles ganz eitel, sprach der Prediger, es ist alles ganz eitel" (Prediger 1,2), roughly "All is utterly vain, said the Preacher, all is utterly vain".6
That depends on the picture. The Museum voor Schone Kunsten Ghent writes about Hendrick Andriessen's "Mancken Heyn" (around 1650) that the oil lamp, soap bubble, skull and bouquet refer to the fragility of life, and tobacco to the insignificance of earthly pleasures.8
The museum calls Andriessen's panel (oil on wood, 50 × 38 cm, inventory number 1914-DE) "a pure example of a vanitas painting". The objects stand in a closed niche that presumably represents the world. And the museum adds: "The image of death is not purely negative: the central element in this composition is a rose, which symbolizes the resurrection."8
The Rijksmuseum owns a "Vanitas Still Life" by the painter Stevers (signed "Stevers", 1630 to 1660, oil on canvas, 45 × 52 cm, SK-A-2358). According to the description, the corner of the table holds a violin, a skull, a Gouda pipe (Goudse pijp), books, an hourglass, a candle in a candlestick, a small casket and two bottles.7 So the Gouda pipe stands next to the skull. What the painter meant by it, the museum does not say, and we do not invent it.
Anyone who reads a warning into every smoking picture reads more into it than the museums write. With Andriessen the museum says so explicitly; with Brouwer and Dou the texts we read say nothing of the kind.
Courbet: the pipe in 19th-century art
With Gustave Courbet the pipe is part of the self-image. The Musée Fabre in Montpellier owns "L'Homme à la pipe", around 1849, oil on canvas, 45.8 × 37.8 cm, inventory number 868.1.18, gift of Alfred Bruyas in 1868. The museum page describes it as a "portrait rêveur" from the artist's bohemian, romantic youth, showing him in a work smock. According to the page, the picture is currently in storage ("En réserve").9 It is worth asking the museum before a visit.
Magritte: Is this a pipe?
René Magritte's "The Treachery of Images (This is Not a Pipe)", in French "La trahison des images (Ceci n'est pas une pipe)", dates from 1929. It is oil on canvas and belongs to the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (inventory number 78.7). According to LACMA, the picture asks whether word, image and object can be reconciled with one another. The design resembles an advertisement, with the cursive script sitting under the pipe like a slogan.10
"Ceci n'est pas une pipe" means "This is not a pipe" and appears beneath a painted pipe in René Magritte's "La trahison des images" (1929, LACMA). The point: the picture of a pipe is not a pipe.10
The Menil Collection in Houston also owns a small gouache with the same title from 1952 (14.6 × 17.8 cm). So Magritte came back to the motif.11
The six works compared
| Work | Museum and year | According to the museum |
|---|---|---|
| Stevers, Vanitas Still Life | Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, 1630 to 1660 | Gouda pipe next to skull and hourglass (listed only). Source 7 |
| Brouwer, The Smokers | Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, around 1636 | Round of smokers, group portrait including a self-portrait. Sources 3, 4 |
| Andriessen, Mancken Heyn | MSK Ghent, around 1650 | Tobacco for the insignificance of earthly pleasures. Source 8 |
| Dou, Man Smoking a Pipe | Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, around 1650 to 1655 | Play with illusion, no statement on the pipe. Source 5 |
| Courbet, L'Homme à la pipe | Musée Fabre, Montpellier, around 1849 | Self-portrait in a work smock, "rêveur". Source 9 |
| Magritte, La trahison des images | LACMA, Los Angeles, 1929 | Picture and object are not the same. Source 10 |
Timeline: from 1590 to 1929
1590 to 1630
Tobacco becomes more popular in the Netherlands across all social classes. In 1609 the pipe-making trade arises. [1]
1630 to 1660
Stevers, "Vanitas Still Life" (Rijksmuseum). [7]
around 1636
Brouwer, "The Smokers" (Metropolitan Museum of Art). [3]
around 1650
Andriessen, "Mancken Heyn" (MSK Ghent) [8]. Dou, "Man Smoking a Pipe" (Rijksmuseum), around 1650 to 1655 [5].
around 1849
Courbet, "L'Homme à la pipe" (Musée Fabre). [9]
1929
Magritte, "La trahison des images" (LACMA). [10]
Smoke is still smoke
A painting shows smoke; it does not judge it. Tobacco-free does not mean risk-free: burning plant material produces carbon monoxide and other combustion products, as the following studies show. A review in ACS Omega (2022) lists carbon monoxide, polyaromatic compounds and N-nitrosamines among the hazardous substances in herbal cigarettes.12
A Korean study (2015) found more carbon monoxide and benzo[a]pyrene in the smoke of a nicotine-free herbal cigarette than in the smoke of a tobacco cigarette with the same tar content; in the test, the condensate was more strongly mutagenic. That concerns a single product, but it shows that "nicotine-free" is no free pass.13
Ritual Herbs is not a health product and not a means of quitting smoking, and is aimed at adults. Anyone who wants to stop can find free advice at rauchfrei-info.de (in German), the portal of the German Federal Institute for Public Health, and by phone on 0800 8 31 31 31.14
Mild and Mild Silver
Finally, what we make ourselves. Mild and Mild Silver consist of the same seven plant components: mullein leaves, blackberry leaves, lotus flower leaves, hollyhock leaves, turmeric leaves, liquorice root and liquorice leaves. Both varieties are tobacco-free and nicotine-free, and the ingredients are listed in full on the pack. The herbs come mainly from Europe, supplemented by selected, wild-picked plants from India; cutting and blending take place in Germany. You can find the range under Tobacco substitute. How other cultures have placed smoking is covered in Smoking cultures of the world.
Further reading
Frequently asked questions
Well known are Magritte's "La trahison des images" (1929, LACMA), Courbet's "L'Homme à la pipe" (around 1849, Musée Fabre), Brouwer's "The Smokers" (around 1636, Metropolitan Museum of Art) and Dou's "Man Smoking a Pipe" (around 1650 to 1655, Rijksmuseum). Add to these Stevers' "Vanitas Still Life" in the Rijksmuseum.3, 5, 7, 9, 10
The picture of a pipe is not a pipe. LACMA describes the 1929 work as a question about whether word, image and object can be reconciled.10
That depends on the picture. The MSK Ghent writes about Andriessen's "Mancken Heyn" (around 1650) that tobacco points to the insignificance of earthly pleasures, while the oil lamp, soap bubble, skull and bouquet show the fragility of life. In the Stevers still life in the Rijksmuseum, the Gouda pipe appears in the description only in the list of objects.7, 8
The picture belongs to the Musée Fabre in Montpellier (inventory number 868.1.18, gift of Alfred Bruyas, 1868). According to the museum page, which we opened in October 2026, it is currently in storage ("En réserve"), so it is not on display. It is worth asking the museum before a visit.9
No. Even without tobacco and nicotine, burning plant material produces carbon monoxide and other substances. A review in ACS Omega (2022) names, among others, carbon monoxide, polyaromatic compounds and N-nitrosamines. With Mild and Mild Silver, tobacco and nicotine are absent; we claim nothing more.12, 13
Sources
- Casna M, Davies-Barrett AM, Schrader SA: Smoking histories: a bioarchaeological approach to tobacco consumption in two skeletal populations from The Netherlands (1300–1829 CE). Postmedieval Archaeology 58(1), 2024. PMC11182213. Accessed October 2026.
- Victoria and Albert Museum: Pipe case (W.151-1928). Accessed October 2026.
- Metropolitan Museum of Art: Adriaen Brouwer, The Smokers, around 1636, Inv. 32.100.21. Data from the Met's open-access record, accessed October 2026 (the web page returned error 429).
- CODART Canon: Anita Jansen on Adriaen Brouwer, The Smokers. Accessed October 2026.
- Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam: Gerrit Dou, Man Smoking a Pipe, around 1650 to 1655, SK-A-86. Accessed October 2026.
- Kunsthalle Karlsruhe: Jacob Marrel, Vanitas-Stillleben, 1637, Inv. 2586; Luther Bible 2017, Prediger 1,2. Accessed October 2026.
- Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam: Stevers, Vanitas Still Life, 1630 to 1660, SK-A-2358. Accessed October 2026.
- Museum voor Schone Kunsten Gent: Hendrick Andriessen, Vanity Piece (Mancken Heyn), around 1650, Inv. 1914-DE. Accessed October 2026.
- Musée Fabre, Montpellier: Gustave Courbet, L'Homme à la pipe, around 1849, Inv. 868.1.18. Accessed October 2026.
- Los Angeles County Museum of Art: René Magritte, The Treachery of Images (This is Not a Pipe), 1929. Accessed October 2026.
- Menil Collection, Houston: René Magritte, The Treachery of Images (La trahison des images), 1952. Accessed October 2026.
- Abdel Rahman RT, Kamal N, Mediani A, Farag MA: How Do Herbal Cigarettes Compare To Tobacco? ACS Omega 7(50), 2022. PMC9773184.
- Bak JH, Lee SM, Lim HB: Safety assessment of mainstream smoke of herbal cigarette. Toxicological Research 31(1), 2015. doi:10.5487/tr.2015.31.1.041.
- Bundesinstitut für Öffentliche Gesundheit (German Federal Institute for Public Health): rauchfrei-info.de. Accessed October 2026.